Contact: nikhilrajgupta09@gmail.com

Love in the Supreme Ethics

Wednesday 17 August 2016

Book Review: Philosophy & the Christian Faith by Colin Brown

Pages: 320, Year: 1969, ISBN-10: 0877847126


Colin Brown is senior professor of Systematic Theology at Fuller Theological Seminary in Pasadena, California. He served as editor of The New International Dictionary of New Testament Theology and is the author of several books, including Miracles and the Critical Mind, History and Faith, and Jesus in European Protestant Thought.

Chapters include:

I. Medieval Philosophy; Augustine and Greek philosophy 2. Metaphysics 3. Anselm and Ontological Argument 4. Aquinas; Five ways and analogy 5. The significance of Medieval Philosophy

II. Reformation thought
Rationalism; Decartes, Spinoza, Leibniz, Pascal, Empiricist; Locke, Berkeley, Hume, Enlightenment; Rousseau, Voltaire, Lessing, Kant

III. 19th century philosophy
1.      Schleiermacher, Hegel and Idealism, Kierkegaard, Atheism and Agnosticism; Feuerbach, Marx and Dialectical Materialism, Nietzsche, Comte and Positivism, Mill and Utilitarianism, Peirce, James and Pragmatism, Darwin.
2.      Trend in theology; Liberal Theology, Catholic reaction, conservative scholarship

IV. 20th century philosophy
Logical positivism, Reaction, Religious language, Existentialism; Bultmann and Tillich, New Radicalism; Bonhoeffer, Honest to God and Death of God
Secular British philosophy; Wittenstein, Moore and Russell, Humanism; Otto, Buber and Teilhard, Neothomis, Reformed theology; Til, Barth, Schaeffer.

He categorizes his work thus; "Histories of philosophy are not normally designed to be read through in bed, and the present one is not necessarily intended to be read through consecutively."
Colin Brown uncovers an astute brief review of alternative philosophical bases of Christian doctrine that influenced the faith of Christians in the course of history. This is an orderly work of an unusually gifted, and intensely dedicated theologian to present an analytical history of philosophy, with an emphasis on the diverse interpretations of the constant encounters of the trends and approaches of philosophy with Christian faith. Colin Brown concludes in the postscript with lessons from the past criticizing the inadequacy of philosophical systems. Although he cautions against reliance on a particular philosophy, he identifies the need of the philosophy's stimulating analysis that pushes Christian theologians to reassess their positions.

In contrast to his planned fast tour of medieval philosophy, he already started to interpret Anselm by Barth and Hartshorne. The author gave the Twentieth Century a comparative elaborate and critical assessment of new drifts in logical positivism, and religious language before he analyses existentialism in the instance of Bultmann and Tillich. He then presents New Radicalism in Bonhoeffer, before his thorough exposition of J.A.T. Robinson's, Honest to God. He would not abstain from analyzing the 'Death of God' movement, but gives his overview on Cornilius Van Till and Francis Schaeffer.

“As we saw when we were looking at theological trends in the nineteenth century, Evangelicals made great contributions to evangelism and even to biblical scholarship; but they contributed little or nothing to the philosophical defense of their faith. For many, scholarship had a largely negative value. It was useful to defend the faith against hostile criticism. Few Evangelicals seem to have considered the philosophical implications of a faith based upon God's revelation of himself and their significance for apologetics." (Pg. 245)

Author closes, "The task of the philosophy of religion is the descriptive and critical analysis of the act, content and presuppositions of belief... It will seek to analyze the phenomenon of prayer, and the validity of claims that are made that God answers prayer. It will be interested in the credentials of alleged miracles (both biblical and otherwise). The question of the existence of evil is one which each generation has to face. It will be especially interested in the Christian claim that God is the creator of the world and its sustainer in the light of the widespread assumption that the world is to be explained entirely in terms of natural causes. The study of philosophy is no task for those who have opted out of life... There are many unsolved problems... But because the Christian is convinced that God is the God of all truth, he will not lose heart." (Pg. 288-289)


Unlike most histories of philosophy, he does not start with the Greeks, but with medieval philosophy (Augustine, Anselm, Thomas Aquinas, etc. The objective of this book is to make a study of the core thinkers and cerebral movements of western thought of the past thousand years, with a view to presenting how they move Christian belief. In just over 300 pages, Brown covers a lot of ideas. For anyone interested in philosophical studies, this is a great introduction to philosophical theology, or for a general overview of the history of philosophy. 


Image Source: http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1348637703l/617084.jpg

0 comments: